Showing posts with label East African Community. Show all posts
Showing posts with label East African Community. Show all posts

Sunday, September 13, 2026

10 points from the AmCham Business Summit 2026

This week, the American Chamber of Commerce, Kenya Summit was held in Nairobi, the 5th edition since 2018. At the summit, President William Ruto highlighted deliverables since his first summit as President in 2023, including removing VAT on exported services, availing tax refunds in 6 months, ending taxation of shares of startup employees, and removing a 30% local ownership requirement for tech companies.



Other notes from the Summit:

1. The contrast since the election of Donald Trump in 2004. From having a former Fortune 500 CEO as US ambassador to Kenya to today, when there are few confirmed US ambassadors in Africa. 

2. The nimble pivot by US diplomats in the Trump era, where foreign policy is defined by mutual benefit. Wind power, which was prominent in 2023, is absent. At the Summit, Frank Garcia, Assistant Secretary of State for African Affairs, said the Trump administration has done 50 transactions worth $28 billion across Africa with leaders who want deals, not lectures. 

3. China is absent in name, but countering it is present in the US strategy: The Lamu port is now in the picture. The US has been there for years for anti-terror reasons, but now it is more prominent as a transhipment centre away from the Middle East. Garcia remarked that deals need peace and economic growth can’t happen without security.

4. Gaining access to critical minerals that are not tied to China is key: Kenya’s Mrima Hills project was mentioned. Also, the Lobito Corridor in Southern Africa is back on track to quickly deliver critical minerals.

5. Quid pro quo diplomacy: Kenya supported the US with troops in Haiti and hosting Ebola patients. Lee Kinyanjui, Cabinet Secretary for Trade and Industry, said that, through such goodwill, Kenya is optimistic about completing a bilateral trade agreement with the USA, which goes beyond gains from AGOA. 

6. Key financial reforms: Angela Ng’ang’a, President of AMCham Kenya, said priorities ahead include rules on transfer pricing and tax cross-border data flows, a more predictable tax regime and harmonization of economic zones framework. 

7. Using Kenya to springboard is now a big play: Kenya connects Nairobi-based US firms to the East African Community of 300 million people, and COMESA of 700 million people, within the AFCFTA market of 1.4 billion.

8. Google, Microsoft, Meta, and Oracle are along for the ride, but a strategic goods control bill at Kenya’s Parliament may facilitate more US technology investments. 

9. Data needs to flow to enable more trade, yet cross-border data flows are hampered by fragmentation, such as data protection laws that vary across countries, affecting digital services, payments, identity, e-commerce, and trade chains. Kenya has just published a paper on cross-border data transfers. 

10. Just when you start to enjoy the East African anthem, you discover there is an African Union anthem that was played by the funky presidential escort band. #AmChamBizSummit


Tuesday, November 10, 2015

Dividend Payments across East Africa - Redux

It’s been four years since this post and the signs are still not encouraging for cross-border dividend payments across East Africa.

Good - Safaricom: I get my dividends by M-Pesa - in fact one came last week, right on the 15th anniversary of the company. At Safaricom, M-Pesa is the preferred method of paying dividends which are below Kshs 70,000 to shareholders - and this would work for almost 99% of their individual shareholders who all own less than 100,000 shares each.

But for Ugandan shareholders of Safaricom, to receive the share of the largest dividend in Kenya’s history ($256 million), they get a cheque in the mailbox  that takes 4 days to clear. The next thing for M-Pesa dividends is to have them automatically reinvested into buying other shares; but for now you can instantly lock the funds away in an interest earning M-Pesa fixed deposit.

No change - Stanbic Uganda: Shareholders in Kenya get a cheque in the mail which takes one month to clear and costs $8-10 per cheque. No improvement, and not likely to change. 

Bad:  (a surprising step back this year is) Bralirwa: At last review, Bralirwa (the Rwanda brewery) dividend cheques were issued KCB Rwanda, and KCB Kenya was encasing cheques at their branches in Kenya provided Kenyan shareholders presented their cheques, and proved their identity - they could receive equivalent cash payments up to RWF50K (~$67). 

This year that option is not there as KCB Kenya is not encashing cheques! A shareholder has to deposit the dividend cheque into KCB or any other Kenyan bank to get they payment.  I tried that at my Barclays branch and they refused as they simply don't have Rwanda francs in their bank system. 

Thursday, October 04, 2012

Possible Economic Bubble In Ethiopia?

-->
A guest post by @Kahenya

Ethiopia has a very positive economic outlook and yes, it has a lot of development going on, but is this sustainable, now that the linchpin (Meles Zenawi) is gone? The one thing that is universal about the entire continent is that the poverty line seems to grow every year, sometimes it shrinks, but only for a moment. The cliché remains, that the rich are getting richer and the poor are getting poorer and there is no true middle class -  and if there is, its only based on people who don't want to imagine that they are less than middle class.

Africa is the kingdom of billion {insert any local currency here} projects. Ethiopia also finds itself in the same quagmire, except for one thing. They are actually making it work for their benefit. In Ethiopia, construction and infrastructure development are at an all time high. It was necessary for this to happen until Meles Zenawi and his beloved Ethiopian People's Revolutionary Democratic Front (EPRDF) went their separate ways, much to the disadvantage of EPRDF. Zenawi's rule transited between dictatorship and benevolence and it was working for him and Ethiopia. Love him or hate him, from being out in the rebel trenches to donning a suit, Meles was every bit a tactical genius. He grew Ethiopia from a war torn country to one of Africa's fastest growing economies. Only Meles could conjure up infinite possibilities. - sometimes by sheer cunning and sometimes by sheer fear.

Hotel cautions on using skype
EPRDF needed Meles to live long enough to get to his end game which would have allowed EPRDF to focus on less ambitious but more people driven development. That did not happen. With him gone, and an open democracy in the horizon (since every linchpin's death or retirement is followed by internal crisis and eventual dissolution, with less political tolerance by the citizens), with a lot of projects still incomplete, and with Ethiopia still facing many financial challenges, the positive economic outlook has quickly shifted from “going to happen” to “may happen”.

EPRDF has moved from the strong offensive, to a sullen offensive-defensive. Push-Pull. Addis, like Luanda, Angola, defies Economic Science. If you buy a vehicle in Ethiopia, when you sell it, even years later, the value generally appreciates. Rents and property rates are astronomically high, coming close to rivaling Luanda – a huge developmental Achilles heel.

Lunch at the  Sheraton in Addis
The key driver of such high rates is the presence of Diplomats and NGOs who have an unending well of money – and this is where the very living ghost of Isaias Afewerki (President of neighbouring Eritrea) comes to haunt Ethiopia. Eritrea, despite being poor, is not dependent on Foreign Aid or NGOs. They have that to pride. For Eritrea, there are no illusions. Poor is poor so the only way is to go upwards - on their own. Ethiopia lacks that. Instead, they have to endure a very faint cushion, one that is rarely successful except in dire times. Unless Ethiopia starts equal distribution of development in the small business sector and begins to really crack the whip on poverty alleviation and shakes off its dependency on NGOs, EPRDF could find itself in a lot of trouble - just like the ANC is, despite them trying to conjure all sorts of ghosts, from Jacob Zuma's incarnation of Umshini Wami to the very living ghost of Nelson Mandela. Nonetheless, Ethiopia's economy is about to get a very shocking reality check.

Monday, November 14, 2011

Guide to Dar es Salaam

A guest post by Josiah Mugambi - @JMugambi to a neighbouring coastal city with good manners and good food, proper Swahili and while Ujamaa is strong, so is government corruption as in Kenya

Getting there: Transport options from Nairobi include road (driving a car or taking a bus for the over 900KM journey) and air with Kenya Airways / Precision Air which is a 1:15 duration. There are at least two flights each way daily, with a return ticket going for about 410$.

The Julius Nyerere International Airport is smallish, and when busy, the queues for arriving passengers waiting to clear with immigration can be long. However. they seemed to be able to handle the large number of arriving passengers reasonably well. On this day, there was a large number of people waiting buy their visas on arrival, however I did not need one as East African citizens ordinarily do not need a visa for stays of less than three months. Visa requirements are easily found online

Once out of immigration, it is possible to change money at one of the few forex bureaus at the airport. (1 USD was equal to about TSh 1770 at the time of my stay)

Getting Around: Taxi's are readily identifiable, mainly white with yellow or green stripes. A cab (most if not all are not metered) from the airport to the Oyster bay area costs about 35-40k Tsh (approximately 20-25 US$) meaning that one to town would be slightly less as it is closer from the airport.

Most people use the "dala dala" public transport vehicles to get around; which are clearly distinguishable. The 'City Bus' operates several routes, which are clearly indicated on the front and side, with fares (nauli in Swahili) starting at 300-450 Tsh ( ~ $0.20) for most city destinations.

'Bajaja's - three wheel Bajaj scooters are another popular form of transport for those who want added flexibility without paying for a taxi. They are however sometimes driven rather recklessly. For shorter distances, some may opt to walk but the hot and humid weather can be a disincentive.

Communications: I was able to use both my Kenyan phone lines in the country. I avoided roaming data (usually expensive anywhere in the world) as much as I could. For internet access, one can get a data modem from any of the four local mobile operators (Vodacom, Airtel, Tigo, Zantel) with Wi-Fi available in some locations (mostly restaurants). I noticed that the mobile market in Tanzania is more evenly spread among the four major operators: Vodacom 37%, Airtel 30%, Tigo 25%, Zantel (Zanzibar focused) 8% (2010 stats from CGAP)

Where to stay, What to eat If you are at the central business district for business, it would be probably wiser to stay closer to town. Reasonable hotel rates start at $100-150 depending on location, and hHtels around Sea Cliff area tend to be more expensive. I stayed at the Colosseum Hotel & Fitness Centre mostly because of the state of the art gym. I also liked the Mediterraneo after visiting it briefly with friends.

Any (modern) economy is heavily reliant on electricity and Tanzania is no exception. I noted that the hotel I was staying at had a backup generator that seemed to go on nearly every night, implying that demand for electricity at peak hours was very high.

One thing that I loved about Dar was the quality of food. Many Kenyans go to Tanzania and say that things happen slower there, but when it comes to food, it's probably for a good reason as most of the time, the food is freshly cooked and delicious (and served in good quantities too!).

I loved the Mshkaki (a form of Kebab, either roast beef or fish) which one can order with lightly roasted bananas - absolutely delicious. If there's anything I miss from Dar it is this! I'm not one for beer, but the average price of a bottle starts at around 1500 TShs ( less than $1), and some (familiar) sodas (Coke, Fanta, Sprite) are sold in 350 ML bottles.

All in all, daily one can expect to spend anything from $10 to over $45 depending primarily on your mode of transport and choice of food.

Language, Stuff to do: Being from Kenya it was not too difficult to communicate in Swahili to locals, though their grasp of the language exceeds that of most Kenyans. I had an interesting conversation with a traffic police lady (after we got pulled over for a routine check) and she said that they (Tanzanians) get really amused about how Kenyans speak Swahili. They are very conscious about grammar while in Kenya we tend to gloss over poor Swahili (unless one is doing an exam of course).

I visited the Mlimani City Complex which is an interesting development bordering University of Dar Es Salaam, with a office complex hosting multinational firms, a shopping centre and a residential park. This is a popular shopping location outside of the city centre with a large supermarket as well as a theatre and several banks. The Sea Cliff area is popular especially for tourists who buy African art, and Tanzanite stones.

I noted that many security guards are armed with a shotgun which lent some semblance of security (unlike in Kenya where your ordinary watchman would have at most a piece of wood to defend himself). Walking around is not advised in lonely places especially on the beach.

As with many coastal areas, the main leisure activity would be visiting the beach. I especially liked Kunduchi beach, situated north of the city centre, with its white beach and from which several wind surfers took advantage of the excellent conditions to show off :). A weekend excursion would be to tale a short trip to Zanzibar by boat, but I was not able to do this.

Economy and Society: In Kenya, there is a lot of talk about corruption, but even in Tanzania many of the locals complain about the corruption that is rife in government. There have been several corruption scandals lately and my taxi guy was rather emotive about the subject.

Mwalimu Julius Nyerere is still highly regarded by many, though some say that he held back economic development somewhat (compared say to Kenya). I however admire the level of social integration present. Unlike in Kenya, there is a distinct sense of unity (possibly due to Julius Nyerere and Ujamaa) and 'negative ethnicity' is virtually unheard of - Something Kenya could learn from its neighbour!

Also, unique, I noticed children holding 'School Children Crossing' signboards at the zebra crossings helping fellow students cross the road, and that drivers respected their right to cross :). Tanzanians are generally courteous and respectful, (a sign of ujamaa?), and generally follow traffic lights and rules - another thing I liked about Dar.

All in all, a good place to visit, especially on holiday.

Monday, October 10, 2011

Reading the Precision Air Tea Leaves

Precision Air (now PLC with a 126 page prospectus at their site) was incorporated as an LLC in 1991. It flies to all major towns in Tanzania Mwanza, Tabora, Musoma, Shinyanga, Kigoma, Kilimanjaro, Zanzibar, Mtwara, Arusha and Dar es Salaam) and internationally to Kenya, Uganda, South Africa, and Comoros. Kenya Airways (KQ) became a strategic investor in 2003, acquiring a 49% stake.

Air Industry: There are 27 air operators in the country, and Precision is the second national carrier of Tanzania with a 59% market share, followed by Coastal Travel 14%, others with 21% and Air Tanzania with 6% (via TAA stats). It is also the only Tanzania carrier operating scheduled international flights and member of the IATA clearing house (ouch!)

Tanzania is a large country with a service industry that contributes 43% to GDP of the country, and id that has increasing air industry opportunities thanks to mining, tourism, but challenges include a lack of staff. Precision has been a local pioneer in e-ticketing (which cost $1 compared to $10 for paper ones), frequent flyer programs and online check-in.

On Offer: Unlike past cross border listing like Bralirwa (Rwanda), Stanbic (Uganda) and Safaricom & Britak (Kenya) which have been available to nationals of all East African countries, the Precision IPO has only Tanzanian and non-Tanzanian categories for retail and corporate investors (no East African category). 51% of the shares are reserved for Tanzania nationals in the case of an over-subscription, Tanzanians can't buy on behalf of non-Tanzanians, and 3% of the shares are reserved for staff of the airline.

If dividends are paid, they are taxed at 5% for both Tanzanians and Non-Tanzanians (shareholders of unlisted companies are charged 10%). Historically, they have paid dividend of about Kshs. 7 million and shareholders equity tumbled in 2011 thanks to a hedging reserve hit of Kshs. 615 million.

58 million new shares are on sale at a price of ~Kshs 29 (TzS 475 each), with a minimum application amount of 200 shares, then multiples of 100 thereafter. The offer runs from 7th to 28th October with results announced on November 11 and listing at the Dares Salaam exchange on December 8 2011.

The IPO has had some delays such as by a small a lawsuit and (threat of) a winding up petition. However the only material litigation mentioned are two (lightweight ones) of a passenger who lost luggage and sued for about $50,000, and some former employees suing for overtime pay of $150,000 which the Precision lawyers note are unlikely to lead to winding up proceedings.

Valuation: With a re-worked earnings per share of 10, the price advised by NIC Capital works to a historical P/E ratio of 50, which is seen as high (see Transcentury [KE] for a similarly listed share)

Cost of Offer: The IPO will cost about Kshs 64 million including payments to Ernst & Young (transaction advisors - Kshs 5M), Orbit (stockbroking - Kshs 3.5M), Stanbic (Receiving bank- Kshs 3M) and the receiving agents (stockbrokers, branches of CRDB, and Stanbic banks all budgeted at Kshs 37M)

Use of Proceeds: hoping to raise about Kshs 1.7 billions (TzS 27 billion or ~ $16 million) and Kshs 700 million will go to fleet expansion, Kshs 400 million for ATR spare parts and the balance in systems, training, equipment and working capital.


Background on Transaction: Michael Shirima, the Chairman had had 1.37 million and KQ 1.32 million shares each. Their shares were split 50 times giving Michael Shirima had 51% (68m) shares and KQ had 49% (66m) and they will retain those shares, alongside the newly created 58 million shares, but which will reduce their holdings to 35.5% and 34.1% respectively

Early partners in the airline's history include Mtengei Materu, Hillary Ngaleku, The Tanzania Venture Capital Fund and East African Development Bank, but at this stage it's only MS and KQ. The company does not own land but has leases from Kilimanjaro Airports Development Company, Kilimanjaro Native Cooperative Union, Quality Plaza Limited and National Insurance Corporation.

Fleet: Comprises 2 ATR 42-320 (All Owned), 4 ATR 42-500 (2 Owned and 2 Leased) 5, ATR 72-500 (All Owned) and 2 Boeing 733: 2 (Leased). ART 42 (4 in fleet) and ATR 72 (5) use 700 litres per hour, with which they fly almost almost 700,000 and forecast flying about 1 million passenger next year. The 737's are maintained by KQ.

Banking: Their arrangements include Citibank ($127 million) who are financing the purchase of 7 ATR aircraft, Stanbic ($6 million) one aircraft and a KCB $6 million) taking over an EADB loan for hangar construction (at Nyerere International airport). They also have letter of credit and guarantee facilities with Stanbic Tanzania.

Human Resource: Precision has 657 staff, but a SWOT in the Prospectus notes that a weakness of the industry is a shortage of pilots and engineers. The Managing Director, Finance, Information Systems and Commercial directors are Kenyans, seconded from KQ who provide manpower development, and training of Precision staff who are attached to KQ. Also at Precision, 4 pilots have been trained from scratch, 12 technicians have been trained at Toulouse by ATR and 5 senior managers are also enrolled in MBA's at Toulouse.

Ground Handling: 150 were employed after the company got approval in 2009 to do their own ground handling - and hope to employ more if they get permission to do the same for other airlines. They do self-handling at Nyerere International Airport (Dar es Salaam) and Kilimanjaro International Airport (Arusha)

Governance: Precision has a lean board with only one independent director and only one committee (audit & risk) that each meets four times a year. As long as they own 20% KQ must be consulted by Precision and agree on the appointment of Managing Director and Finance Director, entry into alliances, new routes, acquisition & disposal of fleet, any issue that dilutes shares, taking on debt. same for MS who holds 20%. KQ and MS have the right to appoint one director for each 10% they have and replace their directors. The IPO also provides for some rights for a minority shareholder who ends up owing 10% shares in the company.

Wednesday, September 21, 2011

Urban Inflation Index: September 2011

One year after the euphoria of a new constitution, the direction of the economy is uncertain as seen in the weakening Kenya shilling, tangles in implementation of the constitution, and rising food prices. It has been a year of some price controls in the fuel, and possibly in the food sector whose parliamentary price control bill was signed into law last week by the President.

Comparing prices to six months ago and last year. On to the index

Gotten Cheaper: Nothing really.

About the same:

Communication: All Kenya’s mobile phone companies have call rates of about Kshs 3 shillings ($0.03) per minute to call across networks. It is unclear what will happen with call rates, as the smallest company in the market, Yu, launched free daytime phone calls, Airtel Kenya lost a CEO, and Safaricom has indicated that they may raise their call rates, as has happened in Uganda with MTN . The real battle is in data, where prices have not really dropped but companies are offering more speeds for less. The market here is divided between the companies with 3G (Orange & Safaricom) who compete on speed, and those without 3G(Airtel & Yu) who offer cheap internet rates of about Kshs 50 (~$0.5) per day for unlimited use.

Another communication developments that, in a way, lower the cost of business include the launch last week at G-Kenya of GKBO, which encompasses free website creation tool, domain registration, and site hosting for small companies by Google in Kenya.

Utilities: The bill on pre-paid electricity is still at about Kshs 2,000 ($21) per month, and getting about 30 – 35 units per buy via M-Pesa. However that is expected to go up after notice was issued for rates to go up 22% per kwh unit. So what alternatives are there? In a somewhat timely move, Samsung launched the NC215, a solar powered netbook laptop last week. It gives 1 hour of power for every 2 hours of charge in the sun, has a 15-hour battery life, and is able to charge other devices by USB even when it is off.

Also got a gift of a solar phone charger (T2126 Hemera from Hirsch) that works quite well; it takes about 12 hours to charge in the Sun or 2 hours via USB, has a flash light and can charge a variety of phone models.

But when you look at the rapid advances in laptop batteries and cell phone batteries over the lasts decade, you get the feeling that there has been a lag in the pace of solar devices, and that more solar based solutions and advances should be emphasized.

More Expensive

Fuel: A litre of petrol fuel, which is regulated by the Government, now costs 117.75 (~$5.6 per gallon) in Nairobi. Regulated fuel has proven to be more expensive than unregulated fuel, and while this can be attributed to the weaker shilling and fluctuating oil prices, the formula used to arrive at the price remains vague, and the limit on margins (stipulated buying and selling price of petrol, diesel, kerosene in each town) appears to have hurt small oil industry companies, more than large ones. However, among the listed companies, Kenol appears to have weathered the regulatory regime better than Total, by having diverse operations in other countries in East and Central Africa that remain unregulated.

Staple Food: Maize flour, which is used to make Ugali that is eaten by a majority of Kenyans daily. A 2kg bag which cost Kshs. 80 six months ago, and Kshs 65 a year ago, is now Kshs 119, the highest it has been in the short history of this index.

Other food item: Sugar : A 2 kg. Mumias pack which has hovered at about Kshs 200 for the last years, now costs Kshs. 385 (90% more than last year) and . The sugar sector has really gone full circle causing many to questions its relevance, recurring shortages shortage (why all factories close at the same month for maintenance), why sugar is grown in a food producing area and how many items we can consume without having to use sugar as a sweetener e.g. tea without sugar, or use of honey as a substitute.

Foreign Exchange: 1 US$ equals Kshs 95.6 compared (now 96.8) to Kshs 80.8 a year ago (and 83 in June 2011) - a loss of almost 20% in a year. It’s unclear of this has been a concern to the Central Bank which has made other confusing policy moves as related to interest rates at a time of mounting government debt and their laxity has enabled banks to spot and take advantage of an arbitrage opportunities to trade with government money.

Beer/Entertainment: A bottle of Tusker beer is Kshs 180 ($1.9) (at a local pub) a slight increase from compared to Kshs. 170 a year ago. However beer has become out of reach for many poorer Kenyan who have resorted to drinking unsafe local brews, which in some unfortunate cases have resulted in blindness or even death.

Thursday, August 18, 2011

Dividends Payments across East Africa

Having bought shares in recent East African IPO's (Uganda: Stanbic Bank and Rwanda: Bralirwa Brewers), there appears to be some progress in addressing one of long standing problems of buying such shares - and this is the bank charges associated with receiving and having to process dividend cheques that are paid in currencies that are fractionally weaker than the Kenya shilling

With Stanbic, the Kenyan arm of the African bank has shown little interest in facilitating this even though a significant number of Stanbic Uganda’s 25,000 shareholders are Kenyan. In fact, the staff pension funds of Kenya Airways and Central Bank are listed among the top 10 shareholders of the bank.

At Bralirwa, the dividends are issued by KCB Rwanda and via a late message, KCB Kenya state they are paying/cashing the cheques up to RWF50K (~Kshs 8,000) across the counter. ( If higher the cheques will be sent for to Rwanda).

While the next step should be for East Africans to receive cross-border dividend payments by mobile money such as mpesa dividends this is only available to Kenyan shareholders. For now, the facilitation of affordable across-the-counter dividends, and other cross border trade & investment payment options is something that banks, not just KCB, with a regional footprint like Equity, Stanbic, Diamond Trust, and NIC should also take up.


EDIT: New communications from the banks show new options for Kenyans who have invested shares across East Africa as follows:

Bralirwa: Any cheques of less than RWF 50,000 (~Kshs 7,750) can be cashed at the counter of any KCB Kenya branch at a fee of RWF 200 (Kshs 31) on production of an ID or a passport

Stanbic Uganda: no certificates will be issued for the 1:1 bonus, and no physical annual reports will be mailed. But shareholders can now elect to receive dividends by electronic funds transfer, or mobile money (airtel money or m-pesa) after confirming their details at Comprite (Uganda) Registrars whose Nairobi office is at Marakwet House, Elgeyo Marakwet Road.

Tuesday, April 05, 2011

NSE Nairobi Investor Briefs

new corporate activities at the Nairobi Stock Exchange include

British American Investments - a.k.a. British American a 46 year old company in the country now planning an IPO at the NSE. They are also embarking on regional diversification as a group, which is best known for its British American insurance (Britak) – but has since added British American asset managers (formed in 2005) and Britam insurance in Uganda.

In 2010 they had gross revenue Kshs. 4.5 billion ($56 million) (up from 3.9 B in 09) largely due to Investment & other income of Kshs 5.1 billion (09 was only 400k) and their profit before tax was Kshs 2.8 billion, compared to a loss of Kshs. 334 million the year before. This also included underwriting income in Kenya of Kshs 152 million (up from 80M year before)

They are aiming for the IPO in 2011 to finance their diversification into micro-insurance and bancassurance as well expansion to Tanzania, Rwanda and south Sudan. They are yet to obtain shareholder and capital markets authority approval. Group Managing Director Benson Wairegi said they have alerted the CMA, but are yet to submit documents until their shareholders approve the process

Kenya's capital markets rules require 3 to 5 years profitability before a company can list, though @coldtusker disagrees with that saying smart investors should be allowed to decide a company's prospects regardless of their recent profitability.

Other: - Their balance sheet grew to Kshs 25.2 billion ($315 million) up from 16.3B. Assets under management by British American asset management (BAAM) grew from Kshs 8 to 17 billion
- Expenses were up 8% compared to 16% for revenue
- Paid a dividend of 200M (Kshs 6.67 per share) up from 120M last year (Kshs 4 per share)
- Bank portfolio: they own 11% of Equity bank and 15.9% of Housing finance

TransCentury: Also up for possible listing is TransCentury which was founded by a Group of prominent Kenyan investors who expand into the limelight when they acquired East African cables in 2004. Since then they have taken stakes in Development Bank of Kenya, Kenya Power & Lighting company as well as Rift Valley Railways

Their 2010 highlights and 2009 detailed accounts show;
- High finance costs eating into profits and need to pay down debt
- Strong shillings bad for there profit 170m impact,
- Kshs 1 billion invested in 2009, down to 50 million in 09

Portfolio - Seem to manage regional diversification better than Olympia did and which Centum is now trying to do
- Quoted shares in Metal Fabricators (Zambia) 20%
- Unquoted in Rift Valley railways (34%) and Development Bank of Kenya

- In 2010, added Cableries du Congo (Congo Cables)
- Chai Bora Blended Tea (Tanzania) [Revenue of Kshs 714M, pre tax loss of 29M]
- Kewberg Cables & Braids [Revenue of Kshs 781m, pre tax profit of 44M]
- Tanelec (Tanzania) [Revenue of Kshs 772M, pre tax profit of 133M]
- Avery East Africa (Kenya scale) [Revenue of Kshs 226M, pre tax profit of 21M ]
- Participation in investment in funds include Kshs 200 million in Aureos (East Africa, South Asia, china), Helios (Kshs 350m) and Business Partners International (Kshs 43 million)

In anticipation of a NSE listing, they made moves such as:
- 10:1 share split in October 2008. Now has 263 million ordinary shares up from 20 million after bonus, split, and new issues
- Paid a dividend of Kshs 13 million in 2009 (DPS of Kshs 0.05). For 2008, it was 29 million, which was part paid in '09
- According to the East African in Feb '11, Transcentury shares were trade at an OTC market run by Dyer & Blair at Kshs 35 per share compared to Kshs 48 in 2010.
- Seem to manage regional diversification better than Olympia did and which Centum is now trying to do

Kenya Airways: Is likely to seek to raise capital from its shareholders this year on advice from their directors and CFC Stanbic who are their financial advisors.

Regional: In Tanzania, Kenya Airways is ceding a steak in Precision Air, which is seeking to raise almost $30 million, in an IPO, but indications are clear that Kenyans will be locked out as will other non-Tanzanians.

From Rwanda, we have the prospect of more share listings from two companies - Bank of Kigali and MTN Rwanda, and following in the footsteps of Bralirwa who's IPO was open to all East Africans.

Friday, November 26, 2010

Reading the Bralirwa Tea Leaves

Brasseries et Limonaderies du Rwanda Limited – (Bralirwa) is Rwanda leading beer brewer and which is now offering shares to the public in an IPO. In the spirit of the East African Community, the shares are offered to residents of all member countries (Read that Tanzania).

In the past, cross border opportunities have been in the case of Safaricom (Kenya) and Stanbic (Uganda) IPO’s as well as with cross listing of a half-dozen Kenyan companies across the exchanges of Kenya, Uganda, Tanzania and soon Rwanda.

from reading the information memorandum (IM)

On Offer: - 25% of company is for sale; being 128.57 million shares at 136 RwF per share (~Kshs 18) and minimum shares are 100, with units of 100 thereafter
- IPO allocation will be 35% retail (Rwanda and EAC nationals), , 5% employees & distributors, 30% international investors, and 15% to Qualified Institutions (insurance, pensions firms) in Rwanda and in EAC – if oversubscribed Rwanda nationals will get 60% in retail pool
- Runs from 23 November to 17 December, and trading begins in February 2011

About Bralirwa: - Current shareholders are the Heineken group with 75% and state of Rwanda with 25%; the shares were split by 5000:1 ratio in November 2010 to facilitate this IPO
- The IPO represents a complete divestment by Rwanda government
-Heineken, the no. 2 brewer in Africa controls the group.
- The company is largest tax payer in Rwanda – accounting for 12% of domestic tax revenue
- Sales in 2009 were $60 million and with a net profit of $11 million
- Subsidiaries include Coglegas (62% of company exploiting methane in lake kivu) and Bramin (50% of a maize processing company)
- Bank borrowing is a fixed interest rate of 12.25% and Bralirwa has unsecured borrowing facilities from Bank of Kigali, Commercial Bank of Rwanda, Fina Bank, Kenya Commercial Bank and Access Bank which have a combined facility limit of Rwf 3.5 billion ($5.8 million)
- Staff benefits for 528 (45) staff listed in IPO include performance based bonus scheme insurance scheme, subsidized mortgages vehicle leases, medical treatment (free of charge), uniforms for school going kids of employees, school fees for orphans of staff killed in 194 and drinks for employees at special occasions
- The company's supply chain is via the the port of Mombasa for clearing and transportation of inputs, and a 1000 KM along the northern corridor through Uganda which takes 3-4 weeks and they use SDV Transami
- Regional competitors - EABL Kenya (Central Glass) and KIOO Tanzania - provide the company with bottles
- Competitive strengths include fact that importing beer from Kenya or Uganda is uncompetitive owing to freight, fuel and insurance costs however high energy costs of US cents 22/kkwh are a challenge.

Incentives: - While effective income tax in the country is 32% in 2011, it can drop to 8% (over 5 years) for companies that sell over 20% of their shares to the public
- 2009 divided was 5.1 billion RwF ($8.5 million) or approximately RwF 50 per share (Kshs 6.5)
- No capital gains tax
- Withholding tax is 5% for Rwanda and EAC residents (but elsewhere IM says all dividend subject to 15% withholding)

Market: - Bralirwa market share in Rwanda in 2010 is 94%
- Rwanda has a Population of 10.5 million people, but per capita beer consumption of 9 litres trails Kenya (11 litres) and Burundi (18 litres!!)

Kenya Links: Bralirwa will be Rwanda’s first listed company, joining Kenya’s KCB, which is the only equity, trading on the Rwanda Stock Exchange. Kenyan influence is strong in the form of KCB (collecting agents), Dyer & Blair (transaction advisors), Faida Securities, Renaissance Capital, Muriu Mungai advocates (legal advisors), and the Central Depository & Settlement Corporation - CDSC (registrars). However Kenyan investors may be currently pre-occupied with their own KPLC rights issue and Deacons private placement

Governance & Registry: - Votes at annual general meeting shall by poll and articles explicitly state not by show of hands
- Company may buy its own shares
- All directors signed the IM document
- IM declares none of the directors are involved in bankruptcy proceedings, or been convicted under criminal proceedings or been judged by a court to have been fraudulent or dishonest (Ethics Kenyan corporates can learn )
- Articles also state – if a shareholder dies, their survivor, executor and administrators only persons recognized to have an interest in the shares

Thursday, September 30, 2010

EABL & Serengeti

East African Breweries is seeking shareholder endorsement of their decision to purchase 51% of Serengeti Breweries of Tanzania. They have sent out a shareholder circular produced by Merrill in London that outlines the nature of their investment.

Partnership: Serengeti will distribute EABL brands exclusively in Tanzania (except duty free shops). Also Serengeti will brew EABL beers but this has not yet started
- EABL will distribute Serengeti products worldwide (the include Premium Serengeti Lager (PSL), The Kick and Uhuru Peak beers, as well as the non-alcoholic Vitamalt Plus)

(image from Christian site writing about beer)

- The deal is contingent on EABL selling its 20% stake in Tanzania Breweries (presumably to Tanzanians), not closing any Serengeti plants while continuing to produce certain Serengeti beer brands for the next five years. (SABMiller still have a 20% stake in Kenya Breweries)

Payment: The EABL Board estimates that it will make cash payment of US$61 million (equivalent to Kshs 4.95 billion) to acquire its 51% stake using reserves or bank facilities (no recourse to shareholders). They will retain $10 million to deal with any shortcomings or deviations in concluding the deal.
- Diageo (EABL’s largest shareholder) has the option to in four years time purchase the remaining stake 49% in Serengeti (not held by EABL) for not more than $600 million. The price is higher but the reasoning is that EABL is investing at an early stag while Diageo will be investing at a latter stage when capacity and synergy gains will have been achieved at Serengeti

Partner: Serengeti is the second largest brewer in the country with a 15% share behind Tanzania breweries (EABL’s previous partner) who have a 72% share of the branded brew market. however unbranded beers command a significant majority of the alcohol consumed in Tanzania – and these include fermented drinks and local beers like Kimpumu (millet beer, is that Tz busaa?), cassava beer, Tekawima (maize beer, is that Tz changaa?) which are highly popular. Serengeti has plants in Dar es Salaam and Mwanza and is developing one in Moshi.
- Serengeti ‘s balance shaeet has assets of about Kshs 4.4 billion (compared to EABL Kshs 38 billion). Their accounts summarized in the circular show drastic changes when produced under Tanzania GAAP generally accepted accounting principles) and international financial reporting standards (IFRS) mainly from change to treatment of bottles and crates (&their deprecation), and revaluation on land & buildings resulting in larger assets and smaller profits under IFRS compared to Tz GAAP
- Current shareholders of Serengeti are Union Brewery holdings, Negus holdings (exiting), Napster group, and V. Mehta (exiting), CMG investment, Mark Bomani and Henry Mosha.

Tuesday, August 17, 2010

Scangroup & Ogilvy Redux

Scangroup shareholders today did their part and unanimously approved the proposed deal to buy into Ogilvy Africa as they also endorsed the creation and allocation of new shares to be swapped under the deal.

This will give Scangroup (thorough Ogilvy) an opportunity and footprint to enter about 8 African countries as a minority partner and links with 15 affiliates, and CEO Bharat Thakar mentioned that creation of a Pan-African agency was fulfillment of a long ambition and the only way to grow the company since the Kenyan (and east African) advertising market was saturated.

The deal still hinges on approval of South Africa authorities for the share swaps (otherwise Scangroup/WPP will have to pay $5 million to complete the deal). By using shares to complete the deal, Scangroup's war chest of cash at WPP is still available and ready to be used to seek majority stakes from these new Ogilvy partners around Africa.

Thursday, July 22, 2010

Karibu Member

On July 20 Equity released their half year results at Equity Centre headquarters in Nairobi CEO James Mwangi mentioned that they are usually the first with results (this time pipped by KCB who are in the middle of a rights issue)

Positive economic outlook: He noted that the picture is much improved from last year; with good agricultural harvests and prices, high exchange rate, government social programs rolled out (Vision 2030 social equity programs for the youth & marginalized), positive progress in the political arena in terms of new constitution, formation of the East African community with 126 million people, remittances are above 2006 figures, tourist arrival are ahead of the 2007 figures, and overall the economy of Kenya is expected to grow by 4.5 – 5% this year.

Bank focus: How does bank focus strategically?
- They have introduce new concept to influence direction of the bank, which for many years operated at micro finance until five years ago went into commercial banking. They have now created structure and are building capacity to move into investment banking (highest IRR per unit of capital), and merchant banking (private equity, venture capital) around east Africa.
- About 400,000 customers graduated to upper and middle SME’s class. They have invested in a level 4 data centre, with a 65 million-card switch and banking platform that can handle 35 million. also boldly claimed that they have overtaken Safaricom to be Kenya’s premier brand
- Innovation will continue through more collaboration with Telco (e.g they have opened 400,000 m-kesho accounts) without agents (yet) and are doing about 20,000 ones per day. Their their dream of opening 10 million accounts is still alive. They are acquiring merchants for visa and MasterCard (3,000 merchants in Kenya) and CBK has approved 4,000 retail outlets to become agents; they want agents to do transaction processing (withdrawals/deposits) at a commission, and equity do loan processing - so when you go buy milk and bread from kiosks, you may be able to withdraw cash

Bank performance: compared to last June
- Added 20 branches (now 165) but none in 2010, and 550 ATM’s (up from 494) and say they have achieved staff stability (5,169 from ,5,056) - no more huge growth in numbers
- Have 4.96 million deposit accounts (up from 3,.9m) and loans 833,819 loan accounts (up from 710k)
- Loans of 68.3 billion (up 27%) deposits 87.8 (up 53%) and assets 122.5 billion (up 40%) – CEO noted that with the economic recover they ate going back to the days when deposits used to grow at 70 % p.a.
- Interest income was 7.3billion (up 45%), commission income 3.8 billion, total income was 10 .1 billion and with expenses at 6.27 billion, (up 36%), profit before tax for teh half year was 3.88 billion [~$48 million] (up 46% from last June)

Summary: He’s optimistic because unlike last year, income is now growing faster than expenses, staff costs grew at 16% compared to previous 40% and asset quality back to 2007 (before Kenya election chaos and drought). The CEO was keen to emphasized that capital base of bank good, and shareholders will not be diluted this year or next year and that their investment in human resource, capital and systems are large enough and stable enough for the next three years, meaning that they can at least double in size without making new investments or seeking new capital.

Q&A

Regional diversification How have Sudan and Uganda performed?
Sudan: Contributed to profit in first year of investment almost ~$2m– not bad for Greenfield. So far only operated in equatorial Sudan, which they can run from Uganda. They have also got lots of corporates to sign with them as their bankings, which used to take 4 days, now takes seconds with equity. The CEO expect S. Sudan to have a peaceful referendum vote next year, which will yield Africa’s 54th state

Uganda: Here, they have been bleeding - in Q1 lost 12b shillings (Kshs 600m), Q2 made los of 3b shillings (Kshs 120m) – but expect to break even this month, and be out of loss in September. In Uganda they made a made mistake, as they did not freeze lending when they bought the other bank - left in the old managers who lent $16 million in 3 months. He believes its much improved; even though they bought a non deposit taking organization, they now have more deposits than loans, (have mobilized Kshs 4b deposits, compared to loans at Kshs 3b) and have 440,000 savers in Ug.

Their increase in provisions in H1 of 2010 (up 211%) is as a result of making a one off hit to clean up Uganda books and the investment was a learning process for them. In hindsight they should have frozen lending and it’s a good lesson they will apply in more countries – the cost would have been much higher if they had made their first outside investment in south Africa or Nigeria and they still have their plan to be in 10 African countries in the next 5 years and now have a 50 member expansion team.

The next foray in East Africa is likely to be Tanzania, earlier they had wanted Rwanda, but there was no easy entry point. But with the new east African community protocol, staff will be able to work without work permits, and it will be much easier to travel across borders

Cyber crime: While he said there have been no hacking attempts on their secure systems, his managers mentioned that there have been attempts to phish or skim originating from eastern Europeans who see Africa as a soft target - however the attacks are not specific to Equity Bank (who are a leading issuer of visa cards) who are on their guard and have not lost through this fraud.

Agency banking opportunities: - From September this year, customers whose salaries pass through Equity will be able to apply for loans from mobile phones or ATM's, not fill out any forms, and automatically get approved a loan (without human interaction)
- They do about 2,500 M-Pesa transactions each day through their ATM’s from which they earn more than normal ATM charges, gettingabout Kshs 50 – 60 per m-pesa transaction as customers come and withdraw amounts that other agents can’t facilitate owing to float

Friday, July 09, 2010

KCB Rights Revolution

($1 = ~Kshs 80
Six years after the first, and two years after the second (reloaded), comes a third KCB shareholder rights issue (a revolution).

KCB (aka Kenya Commercial Bank) is Kenya’s largest bank by assets [Kshs 221 billion (~$2.75 billion)] and has 210 branches in Kenya, Rwanda, South Sudan, Tanzania and Uganda. Separately, a Central Bank of Kenya audit report for 2009 shows it has the 3rd largest number of deposit customers at 751,852, behind equity 4 million and co-op 970,000 and followed by Barclays, 748k and Family 574k.

In 2004 and 2008 they surpassed their fund-raising targets and raised 2.3 billion and 5.2 billion respectively. This time they are aiming for a much larger amount Kshs 15 billion (~$188 million), by offering 887 million new shares to their shareholders at Kshs 17 ($0.22) per share, in the ratio of 2 new ones for every 5 held – adding to the issued 2.217 billion shares and representing a 40% increase.

The issue is not underwritten and is subject to a minimum subscription level of 50% i.e. must raise at least 7.5 billion. The shares will also be available to other east African investors in Uganda, Tanzania, and Rwanda. Rights also provided a way for shareholders to buy shares for close relatives by way of private placements.

The prospectus (IM) (PDF) was not mass mailed this time, but is available only from their web site, stockbroker, and branches of the bank.

comparisons to the last rights issue in 2008
Then (June ’08) ; Now (July ’10)
- Target 5.2 billion ; 15.8 billion (~$190 million)
- Focus: then - East African expansion, Bank ESOP ; Now - grow mortgage business and other growth (if funds are raised, 13 billion will be used in Kenya, 1.5b in Uganda, 894m in Tanzania , 473m in Rwanda) Negative funds marked for Sudan and elsewhere the IM notes that KCB with 5 branches has 34% of the Sudan market by assets
- New shares 222.1 million ; now 800 million
- Price : then - 25/= ; now – Kshs 17/=
- Allocation: then : 1 for 9 : now 2 for 5
- Market cap: then – Kshs 66.4 billion, now – Kshs 47.6 billion?
- Profit after tax then - 2007 2.9 billion ; Now - 2009 - 4.5 billion
- Result: then oversubscribed; now, may fall short

Budgeted cost of the offer: 2008 - 220 million : 2010 - Kshs 446 million ($5.5 million)
What costs more? : CMA approval fees – up 360% (kshs 37.5m), Transaction advisor – up 288% (31.5 million), PR/advertising – up 300% (69.4 m), Legal advisor up 190% (2.2 million) NSE fees up 10% (500,000)
What costs less? Reporting accountant (3.8m is unchanged from last time so virtually a decrease), and no figure given for printing costs which should be substantially lower than last time as they are not printing & mailing a copy the 116-page prospectus to each of the 169,076 shareholders

Market players: The lead sponsoring stockbroker is Standard Investment Bank and they are also the lead transaction advisers along with KPMG. In Kenya, there are 18 NSE members selling the shares [including discount securities under statutory management, and reliable securities (in which Old Mutual acquired a 70% stake)] as well as 6 commercial banks with large branch networks - Stanchart, Equity, National, Co-op, Barclays and KCB itself)

The rights issues is also open to foreign investors who are East African nationals who can buy shares through;
- In Tanzania: 6 investment banks (including Core, Orbit, Rasilmali, Solomon, Vertex)
- In Uganda: 20 investment advisers and stockbrokers (include crane, MBEA, African alliance, Crested, DFCU, Stanbic, Devere)
- In Rwanda: 8 investment banks (including MBEA, Dallas, Continental, and a trio of Kenyan offshoots - (dyer & Blair Rwanda, kingdom, Faida)

Shareholders: Anchor shareholders - then and now :
Government of Kenya (26%:23%), NSSF (7.8%:5.23%), ICDCI (3.5%:3.36%), Sunil shah, (2.33%:2.33%) staff pension fund (2.32%, now out?). In terms of directors, no change except that the IM shows that Group CEO sold his entire individual shareholding between 12/09 and 7/10 while another has decreased hers by about 70% (none have

At the record date, KCB had 169,076 shareholders who included other East Africans (12 institutions, 198 individuals) and foreigners (55 institutions, 438 individuals)

Calendar: Record date 18/6, rights start trading 1/7, last day trade rights 12/7, last date to pay for rights 23/7, new share trade 19/8,

Verdict: The rights started trading at over 1 shilling, but in the span of a week have dipped by 50% to about 0.5 shillings per share. Stockbrokers say that demand is good for the shares but that they anticipate the Government and one other top shareholder (one on CNBC said it would be the NSSF) are foregoing the offer and selling their rights before the offer lapses leading to the dip in the rights price.

Investment analyst have variously complained about the massive amount of shares being listed, dilution of existing shareholders, and the large amount of money being raised by the bank, which they doubt has the capacity to utilize the infusion efficiently. One analyst from Renaissance Capital said they had downgraded KCB when the rights issue was announced.

Tuesday, December 15, 2009

African Business Outlook for 2010

Africa Practice: A survey of business executives conducted by Africa Practice, a consulting firm, reveals some interesting perspectives for the coming year:
- 68% of the interviewees expect to expand their businesses significantly
- 100% expected FDI to increase in 2010 (mainly from china) (up from 69% in 2009)
- Leading business challenges are access to credit (30%) and availability of talent (35%)
- No change in US administration impact on Africa
- Increased intra-African business and moving away from a reliance on international exports was cited as key in Africa’s private sector development
- The most significant development will be technology investments and reduced costs communions costs (56%)
- But, just 54% believe that economic benefits from the 2010 world cupwill be felt only in South Africa itself.

Economist: Also writing on the World Cup is the Economist which notes

the more pressing question is whether South Africa will benefit from the World Cup. New airports and roads will attract more foreign investment to provincial cities, ...but the boost in tourism in poorer country areas will hardly offset the broken promises of investment by the crony-ridden African National Congress. And the newly built stadiums will be filled only occasionally by the national rugby team.

A worry for FIFA is that the tournament will not be African enough...There will not be many fans travelling from qualifying African countries. Many black South Africans will not be able to afford even the subsidised ticket prices for matches; gifts of tickets to nurses and teachers will be needed. So Africa’s moment may be uncomfortably white.

The article is part of their annual the The World In (2010),and this issue also has an article crowning neighboring Somalia as the worst country on Earth and which reads like it was conjured up for the satire in the onion

Standard Chartered: Also an interesting read is this future wealth report from Stanchart.

Thursday, April 30, 2009

NIC Bank 2009 AGM

The 2009 annual general meeting (AGM) of NIC Bank took place on Wednesday April 29 at the Kenyatta International Conference Centre Nairobi. (more on the background and recent performance of NIC)

The Chairman JPM Ndegwa (Chairman) led the meeting which began after the Company Secretary making some housekeeping announcements – mentioning lunch would be served afterwards but members should not litter the building as they eat, asked shareholders to switch off their mobile phone (a few still rang during the meeting) and that the bank had a marketing desk where their products would be on display for shareholders to ask questions and could open share accounts

Chairman Performs: The Chairman introduced the board and the management and representatives of S&F Bank of Tanzania who were seated at the side of the dais. He spoke throughout the day in a mix of English and fluent Kiswahili. He began by commenting that the 2008 AGM held at Safari Park Hotel had been quite crowded hence the move to a larger venue (bank has almost 25,000 shareholders)
Most important was how he controlled the tempo of the meeting, by stating upfront that only relevant questions should be asked and only as related to what was being discussed or voted on at each time. The result was one of the most constructive Q&A segments I have seen, with no frivolous questions asked during the session and the meeting progressing quite rapidly

Financial accounts 2008: the bank ended the year with a profit of Kshs. 1.48 pre-tax billion (~$18.5 million) and significant growth in assets deposit and loans. After the audit partner (Mr. Ndonye from Deloitte & Touche) read out their opinion, there were no questions and the accounts were approved!

Dividend: a final dividend of Kshs 0.25 for a total for the year of Kshs 0.5 was approved by shareholders. The voter elicited a couple of the shareolder to as usual ask for a higher dividend to be paid than the board had recommended. Another shareholder asked that, since the dividend was meager, could they be paid a bonus share?he clearly had not read or listened to the agenda

Directors fees – while you can’t compare the level of disclosure to shareholders at Stanbic (Uganda), the Chairman stated that the total sum paid to non-executive directors was Kshs 5.2 million ($65,000) – in sitting allowance for board & committee meetings. This was actually lower than the 5.36 million paid the year before last yearn and the results were plain to see. Vote was approved

Auditor Re-elections: the directors recommended that Deloitte continue in the accounting roles and asked shareholders to approve that; one shareholder asked if Deloitte was the only firm considered and if so why the Central Bank (CBK is bank regulator) also had to approve the appointment of the auditors – was there a problem with Deloitte? The chairman answered that they used other audit firms, and that there were provisions that firms could not consult and audit at one company and they were quire satisfied with the work Deloitte has done. He added that Central Bank , in looking out for depositors interest, also vetted audit firms employed by banks to see that they were competent (an aside is that the recent ‘enhanced rules’ for stockbrokers don’t specify their quality of their auditors or indicate that the CMA will even vet them)

Director Re-Elections: Isabella Ocholla Wilson and George Maina were re-elected as directors; so was lawyer Michael Somen who required was an extra vote since he is over the age of 70 years He’s the Chairman of Access Kenya, but it seems NIC have a habit of de-emphasizing their directors board positions on other companies

Bonus share : The next motion, for NIC shareholder s to receive 1 new bonus share for each 9 they own produced the first unscripted moment of the day and the hot button issue was again - rogue stockbrokers - three different shareholders asked the same question - i.e. NIC was giving them a bonus share, which they would be forced to take to a stockbroker who may sell this shares without their knowledge, or collapse with their shares/funds. The Chairman replied NIC Bank now had their own stockbrokerage firm NIC capital Securities where their shares would be safe. The war by banks against stockbrokers is still being waged in public – and a few days ago it was Equity Bank shareholders who were being given the same message –that their shares were safer with the strong commercial banks that they know and own, rather than with some small stockbroker

Purchase of 51% of S&F Bank: NIC is purchasing 51% of Savings & Finance, a Tanzanian Bank for a total cost of Kshs. 580 million (~$7.25 million). Continuing part of expansion and diversification since their 2007 rights issue that has seen them open branches in Kenya, an now make a cross-border investment ; the vote brought out the most questions of the day;

Q. exchange rate change since deal was announced; why is some payment in Tanzania shillings and some in US$?
- mix of currencies is s how the Tanzanian owners requested it be paid. - the shillings is weaker and they are now paying about 2.1x book value compared to 1.9x earlier. Also some S&F shareholders live outside Tanzania
Q. The owners seem to be family/private individuals:
- True most companies start with individual shareholders only - and the institutional shareholder is the East African Development Bank. S&F was started in the 1990's and it origins were in hire purchase business are similar to NIC. The shareholders with 49% are also going to be re-investing the NIC money in the banking, not taking it out.
Q. why is the bank attractive? Is it a leading bank in Tanzania – where does it rank?
- Tanzania has 28 banks and S&F would be between no 15 and 20. NIC felt they would get best value by acquiring a small bank and driving its growth. NIC directors did their due diligence, have observed S&F operations, got transaction advice and confidential banking reports from Tanzanian regulators confirming the bank was a good buy . It has 3 branches in Aruaha, Dar es Salaam and Mwanza which are all key trading points. MD added that - NIC was not the only suitor interested in S&F.
Q. How will it be run?
- S&F will have 7 board members – 4 nominated by NIC (including the MD’s post) and 3 by S&F (including the Chairman’s post - Abdulsultan Jamal). NIC have opted to retain the current Tanzanian MD – Suranjan Ghosh, Mark Bomani (former Tanzania attorney general) and Andrew Ndegwa (Kenyan NIC director) and James Macharia (Kenyan NIC managing director) as their four nominees.
Q. Other Kenyan banks have focused on Rwanda Uganda and Sudan- why Tanzanian (which has not been receptive to other Kenyan companies
-Chairman replied that Kenyans were the biggest investor in Tanzania (excluding the mining sector). Also in terms of diversification, the election violence of 2008 affected Kenya, Uganda and Rwanda equally - since countries were on same trade route! However Tanzania was a completely different market. A large untapped country with great agricultural and resource potential. Many NIC customers do business there already.
Q. Deal wrap up?
- Approval has been got from Central Banks of Kenya and Tanzania. After NIC shareholders voted to approve the deals, it is now expected to be wrapped up on Monday next week and S&F will become a subsidiary with their accounts consolidated in NIC’s from next month.

Goodies: a souvenir wall clock

- Smart NIC had a boxed lunch served to shareholders (much easier to manage than any buffet and needs fewer catering staff). each box had cold roast chicken piece, beef sandwich, juice, water bottle, cup cake, and an apple.

Friday, April 17, 2009

Ugandan Envy

this is NOT about Migingo Island


Google Earth image courtesy of afromusing


A year ago wrote this on the information availed to Ugandan investors by their companies; this year the envy is even more, it makes me sad; that by being the leading country in the region, we may not notice we are being passed in some aspects of investor awareness & rights.

Use of E-Mail: The Stanbic Uganda invitation/AGM notice again arrived by e-mail; now many Kenyan companies have passed by-laws allowing them to send out e-mail notices and annual reports to shareholders, but none has done so far. Maybe, with the eventual passage of the much maligned/controversial communications bill the legal framework is now there to back enable this – but we’ll see; While not every shareholder will have an e-mail account, if 1/4 of 1/3 of some company’s shareholders (Kengen, Co-Op, Safaricom) do, then these companies could potentially saves millions of shillings in postage costs.

Investor Disclosures:
(i) For Stanbic UG, rules of voting are clearly stated – shareholders are to endorse new directors and that 1/3 of directors will retire at each meeting.
(ii) for directors who are up for election, their mini-CV’s are printed out for all to peruse i.e. their ages, year of appointment, educational qualifications, directorships in other companies, and committee seats they. In Kenya, Company Chairmen just mumble through, if at all, fully expecting elections to be a foregone conclusion. Refreshingly here, the directors up for election at Stanbic Uganda (Hannington Karuhanga, Kitili Mbathi, and Samuel Sejjakka) are all younger than 50 years. In Kenya, opportunities for younger leaders & directors are the exception rather than the rule. But at Stanbic Uganda - the Chairman and Deputy Chairman have their tenure is capped at two terms of 5 years only.
(iii) Remuneration of directors is declared. Again in Kenya money amounts paid to directors are rarely mentioned, but in Uganda they are spelt out for shareholders to approve – here the Company (non executive) Chairman gets an annual retainer of US$7,500 while a director gets US$5,500

Language used; several companies (most recently) KCB have amended their company article to allow for electronic communication with clients; but they merely replace one of gibberish with another one, without bothering to explain what the jargon means. Here; Stanbic explain allows video-conferencing or tele-conferencing to be used at board meetings

Proxy detail proxy forms contain a lot more details including the items to be voted for with shareholder able to vote for or abstain on votes. They also call for shareholders to provide contact details (name, e-mail – what an easy way for a company registrar to build up a working database to manage is subsequent years)

Shareholders or their proxies (who can be more than one)are entitles to attend, speak, and vote, and the endorsement /presence of a proxy does not disqualify a shareholder from attending; this enables a shareholder to bring his wife/wives or children for them to learn about the process!

==

Investor guides: There are many things to learn from other countries in the region on investor rights and information despite Kenya being the leader. We are innovative, Uganda is about to unveil a CDSC system that Kenyan investors have had for three years, but which rogue stockbroker have besmirched. It would not be surprising if the Ugandan version may be sorted out ahead of time, closing loopholes that will be used to protect shareholders, and by educating them on how the system works.

All the regional exchanges – Kenya, Tanzania, Uganda, and soon Rwanda (where KCB, Kenya’s largest bank in Kenya will be the first company to have its shares to be (cross) listed & trading) all have the same information; but my NSE seems stale, like all the regulations were put up years ago and forgotten. Usualy we just check for the latest share trades, bond trades and quarterly financial announcements.

e.g. Faced with a budget deficit, Kenya has lowered the minimum amounts to invest in bonds to Kshs. 50,000 ($625). The Central Bank of Kenya which issues these bonds has put up some investor information basics, but nothing from the NSE who trade in these bonds. In Uganda, there is an advisory page for investor guides for bonds and shares, for any new investor to read, download for free.

Also in Kenya , tribe is the unacknowledged elephant in the room; one we pretend to not be influenced by, but which governs many aspects of our lives. Kenyans are required to communicate official in English (almost all government documents), and to a lesser extent in Kiswahili. But there are rural folk who may not understand the national or official language, but may wish to learn about shares and bond Uganda has investor awareness booklets in vernacular languages – including a Luo investor guide (PDF)(for the Northern Region) available from the Uganda Securities Exchange. And that, properly disseminated, may be worth much more than a small island.

Friday, May 09, 2008

Regional diversification

Taking regional investments a step further - how are various local listed companies doing on the regional front? January 2008 showed that having a focus on Kenya alone could be an Achilles heel despite it being considered one of the strongest economies in the region. Various listed companies are making pushes in East and Central Africa – however many of these countries are all dependent on Kenyan access, hence its not really true diversification of political risk. In that sense, Olympia Capital, an NSE laggard may be ahead of its peers with its tangled Botswana and South African corporate moves.

here’s a recap:

- CMC says regional sales are on target in Uganda and Tanzania (from ½ year results this week)
- Diamond Trust has set its sights on Burundi (adding to Uganda and Tanzania) while many other banks have targeted Rwanda
- East Africa Cables attribute good performance to their subsidiaries in Uganda, Rwanda and Tanzania
- KCB has subsidiaries in Uganda, Tanzania and S. Sudan (though it wrongly had the flag of Sudan on its’ annual report cover. These countries contribute less than 10% to their income and Ug had a loss of 49 million (setup costs) while Tz barely broke even with a profit of 0.2m in 2007. KCB opened in Kampala in November 07 and will open 6 more Ug branches in 2008, 4 new ones in S. Sudan in 08, and another 20 new branches in Tz over the next two years according to their annual report
- Kenol who after acquiring Kobil could be the first 100 billion shilling turnover company, have subsidiaries in Uganda, Tanzania, Rwanda, Zambia and Ethiopia. 80% of their sales are from Kenya, while the other countries contribute about 20%.
- TPS East Africa acquired 8% of Serena Rwanda which includes Kigali Serena and Lake Kivu Serena. Of Serena's 2007 sales of Kshs. 3.7 billion (~60 million), Kenya accounted for 64% and Tanzania 36%.
- Total Oil Kenya has sister companies in Uganda, Tanzania Congo Rwanda so essentially remain a Kenyan company with 97% of their sales being local. They however complain in their 2007 report that other countries who should be buying from Kenya are (because of our tax regulations) buying offshore and shipping through Kenya instead.
- Sameer Africa are looking for transporters to Somalia, DRC, Ethiopia, Rwanda, Sudan, Burundi, Mozambique, Zambia, Malawi Uganda and Tanzania for their products.

Saturday, May 03, 2008

Regional banks and dueling websites

Diamond Trust Bank will this month ask their to approve
- participation of the bank in a rights issue of their Ugandan subsidiary
- Approve expansion to Burundi (odd or smart considering that other banks have focused on Rwanda)

dueling web sites

DTB new corp name have a new website but they should probably map /discontinue their old site or it may give the impression that its another company that doesn’t bother to update its website.

KCB who are also going to increase their capital to support regional expansion, and cross listing on the stock exchanges in Tanzania and Uganda, have consolidated their company to a group website, abandoning their kcb.co.ke

Also caught up in the confusion of domains between (.co.ke) and (.com) is the Safaricom IPO. The former is the official site, which applicants could use to apply online for shares. The government should have cracked down on transaction adviser - Dyer & Blair who opened the latter site and may have created some confusion. Though more active and up to date (even has a blog of sorts), the Dyer site attracted people who thought it was the official site and some confused investors have been logging in their to track their applications without realizing that it is not the official site

Wednesday, April 30, 2008

Sleeping giants may never wake (or reform)

labour on Labour Day
Sometimes I wonder if we are ever going to reform & develop, or if by being profitable and making money we see no need for some reforms - corporate, land, ICT, political or other.

Rwanda is on the fast path to being an ICT powerhouse. They may get there, but we have the beach, undersea cable etc. - all we have to do is wait to benefit from them. Uganda and Sudan have oil – but so what? It will have to pass through here.

Stanbic Uganda [Pre tax profit of 69 billion ($41 million) [up 37%] and a dividend of Ug. 6.64 shillings per share (up 10%)] is able to e-mail to shareholders their annual reports, AGM notices, and proxies; meanwhile many Kenyan companies talk about it, have amended their by-laws to enable it, but I'm yet to see it done (any examples? - but maybe having 1 million expensive shareholders will entice them to take the next step forward).

In Uganda, empty plots display their legal numbers and have some sequential order by street; here in Kenya L.R. no’s (the official designation of parcels of land) only appear in court documents/mentioned in scandals and are only understood by estate agents.

In Uganda the Central Bank publishes all bank charges in the newspapers for customers to compare; here they give them to some private agency (FSD Kenya) to interpret for customers.

While the Kenyan audit bodies (FIRE, ICPAK) fault our companies for not disclosing the director compensation which they ask their shareholders to dutifully approve at each AGM, Stanbic Uganda shareholder can see that their chairman earns $10,400 and what each board member earns ($1,700 to $4,250) for them to approve.

Lastly, I don’t know any Ugandan stockbrokers but I’m sure it’s easier to ascertain their performance (and avoid rogue brokers) than it is here.

Thursday, April 10, 2008

Regional IPO Tales

Undugu gani huu?: One of my favorite entertainment sites is Bossip with its catchy headlines, like Making it Rain on These ****, Jesus Take The Wheel, and ** sit down, all of which apply in this case, but the best way to answer this story is BROTHER PLEASE! - while Uganda and Rwanda have joined thousands of Kenyans embracing the investment vehicle that is the Safaricom IPO, it appears the Bank of Tanzania is preventing Tanzanians from buying shares in Safaricom through the Dar es Salaam Stock Exchange. (hat tip RO)

Africa investment resource: africanshareholder.com is a great site to keep up with investment happenings in Africa.

Celtel IPO On: Sadly, not in Kenya, but in Zambia starting at the end of April – with 20% of the local subsidiary on offer.

Executive privilege: one reason that ministerial seats/portfolios are in great demand in Kenya is the power that comes with then such as the authority to insert one’s buddys' names on state corporation (parastatal) boards and these become law once they run in the weekly Kenya gazette. Sometimes one can even create new boards such as the new Brand Kenya Board which has been formed to market Kenya in the fields of tourism, investment, creditworthiness and international relations.

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails