Saturday, August 13, 2005

Kenya Airways 2005 AGM

Kenya Airways held its 2005 annual general meeting at the Bomas of Kenya auditorium on Friday August 12th

Erase 2004 memories
The airline was determined to avoid a repeat of the chaos that marred its 2004 meeting at the Carnivore. Some of the improvements made include:
- They provided free transportation by City Hoppa shuttle to and from the railway station to Bomas
- They handed out lunch boxes at the entrance to shareholders after registration (around 10 in the morning) along with a gift bag (with t-shirt and water bottle) – (some shareholders immediately turned round and left having got their objective for the day)
- They also set up an additional Hall at Bomas with A/V conferencing so that excess numbers could be accommodated and participate in the AGM.

Who’s Chairman?
Lawyer Dinesh Kapila was the company & board chairman today. Mr. Omolo Okero was also seated on the dais as a board director for the last time, after resigning as Chairman two weeks ago, at the end of July. Kapila will chair the company until the newly constituted board of directors elects a new chairman next week.

Mr Okero never said a word the whole meeting, sitting quietly as shareholder after shareholder repeatedly called for him to be commended for steering the company to great heights during his 14 years on the board, 10 as chairman. Strangely, the company has not seen fit to honour him with a fitting farewell, as Barclays did for their retiring Chairman, Sam Ambundo at their AGM. Maybe the company has something planned or perhaps has some reason for not wanting to honour Mr. Okero better.

Mr. Kapila is a no nonsense lawyer, with a relaxed style who ran his first KQ AGM like the pro that he I – having no doubt chaired other meeting and made presentations before courts and companies. He introduced the board, management, company secretary and auditor’s report in about ten minutes before opening the floor for shareholder questions.

Shareholder queries
The first questions were by shareholder Mr. A. W. Chami who I have seen at every AGM I have attended over the last one year. He asked why borrowing was up, and all the loans were from Barclays UK Company Response: debt is from fleet expansion and Barclays made the best offer

Dividends: More than 1/3 of the questions asked, were requests for increased dividends. In 2004 the company paid a dividend of 0.75 shillings per share (from earnings of 3.14) and this year they proposed to pay 1.25 out of earnings of 6.54 per share. Many felt this was too little and that the company should either pay interim dividends, convert revenue reserves, stop giving sumuni dividends (50 cent dividends), give bonus shares, pay a special dividend to honour chairman Okero, hand out actual cash or even forego giving lunch – all in a bid to pay more dividends. Company Response: Most earnings are retained as the airline must have huge amounts of cash available at all times since the industry is very unpredictable and also for fleet expansion

Fuel: Oil prices are cause for concern. They constitute 26% of airline cost, and oil prices are 61% up from a year ago. CR: the airline hedges its fuel costs for 3 months, and is considering adding a fuel surcharge to passenger tickets

Women: There are no lady board member can the company rectify that? CR: KQ has had women directors before such as Dr. Eddah Gahukia, and more women should apply for director elections

Drugs: KQ’s “Pride of Africa” image is being tarnished by repeated arrest of KQ employees for drug trafficking, perhaps they should pay their staff better? CR: drugs are a national problem bigger than KQ and caused by greed. The airline plans to employ some sniffer from later this year

Directors: Shareholder concerns included;
- Directors elections are a sham, as the two majority shareholders (KLM: 26% and the Kenya Government: 23%) call the shots.
- They proposed maximum terms of 8 years for directors to serve.
- There are no true minority shareholders on the Board. All directors of the company hold 3 to 4 other jobs elsewhere.
- Directors should eat lunch with shareholders and hear more of their concerns

Government: Finance Permanent Secretary Joseph Kinyua was present as a board member and he confirmed that the government will not be selling off is 23% shareholding saying that the KQ is national airline it is in the strategic interest of the Government to retain its minority shareholding in the company.

Fleet: Why buy new 777 planes instead of leasing? CR: At the time the decision was made, buying new aircraft was the only available option as leasing companies were not comfortable with the airline’s position. But now the airline is better established they will in fact be leasing 737-800 aircraft next year to replace some 737-200 planes

Privileged shareholders: Can shareholders get preference by giving them discounted air tickets or employing their relatives? CR: KQ carries 180,000 passengers a month and if they give each of the company’s 80,000 shareholders discounted flights they will have no profits to report. Also the airline has no favours/does not discriminate in employment matters

Funny: Questions that got the most laughs;
- The font in the annual report is too small
- Dividend so pitiful that street kids will not accept it if it is thrown at them.
- Now that shareholders all have their lunch (boxes), the meeting could go on till 5 p.m.
- Directors should be elected on the floor by acclamation not by secret ballot
- One shareholder wondered if he could get the gift bag he missed at last year’s meeting

Immediately after the AGM ended, reporters rushed off for a separate media only briefing (no bloggers) to get some straight talk from management, away from the shareholders nonsense. Later on TV, MD Naikuni was shown denying that he had a conflict with former chairman Okero. I feel the media should pay more attention to shareholder questions as they sometimes bring out some candid answers from the Board.

There were three director vacancies, which were created by Dr Chris Obura, Neil Canty (the airline Finance Director, and Mr Omolo Okero retiring. Canty and Obura offered themselves for re-election while Okero retired for good.

Others candidates were
- Joram Kariuki – former NBK manager and politician
- Japeth Rob, a HR manager, vocal shareholder and a perennial candidate
- Evans Mwaniki, the Chairman of BAT Kenya and former shell executive
- Ayisi Makatiani, founder of Africa Online
- Also one lady got was on the panel, but she was absent today.
- Surprisingly, Paul Wanderi Ndungu, a lawyer with a substantial number of KQ shares (he’s the #4 shareholder with 2.14%) withdrew his candidacy at the meeting.

I predict that Dr. Obura and Neil Canty will be re-elected. The third slot will be a fight between Evans Mwaniki and Ayisi Makatiani. Audited election results will be published in the Tuesday paper.

All work and no play...

On the way out, I had my first view of the new and much raved about Land Rover Discovery LR3. It was being driven by KQ MD Naikuni.


Afromusing said...

Very insightful as always, thank you.

Anonymous said...

I see you got hit by the Anon monster!!

Great round-up. Wish the media would be as concise as you B. Or maybe you should just, you know, write a business for dummies column.

Anonymous said...

Had lots of fun reading it!

Some observations:
- Group EPS was 8.40. The Company "Kenya Airways" is just one facet of the Group which includes KenCargo, etc.

- Dinesh Kapila is "interim" chairman.
- Dinesh Kapila is a good choice esp with the experience he has in KQ. Will being a Mhindi knock him out? He has KLM's (not Govt)support as seen in the elections 2 years ago.
- Mwaniki coz he is already chairman of another high profile firm. Is he a friend of the govt?
- KLM directors? I doubt coz of the "KLM domination" perception.

Naikuni & Canty can't be the chairman coz Executive Chairmen are not allowed.

KLM nominates the MD & FD thus no matter what the most 2 important Board positions are KLM's choice. AND I say YES to that! Would you trust the govt? We would be sourcing 2nd hand Soviet planes like we do army helicopters!

Anyway... I think Mwaniki will win out over Ayisi. That said I am surprised that Ndungu withdrew coz I am sure with some lobbying he could have garnered many more votes as long as KLM & govt didn't gang up on him.

I like the idea of providing the lunch boxes & gift bags sooner so as to get rid of uninterested shareholders early on!

Next time... I say bankelele gets to be part of the media!

Anonymous said...

KQ should do this on a Saturday to allow more shareholders! Can you imagine how many more would show up?

BTW, unlike your Barclays blog, you never did tell us what was in the lunch box?

bankelele said...

Afromusing: thanks, it was a fun day and event

Ms K: I hope this is the last monster I see.

Anonymous: suprise election result, as Dr. Obura was voted out, and Makatiani & Mwaniki join the board.

bankelele said...

Anonymous: my collection for the day was

gift bag: red tote bag had red t-shirt (w/new KQ logo), Sprite bottle and a Keringet water bottle branded in KQ colours (still unopened, but there's no Kenyan E-bay yet to hawk this stuff)

Lunch Box: By Panafric Hotel (Sarova group) had cold chicken piece, plain ham sandwich, small yoghurt cup, apple, orange, small cake, and small ribena)

Anonymous said...

great articles and will be looking forward for your updates, you can also catch on blog below

Anonymous said...

I need a link on this page.
If you need a link in return then mail me at
plz be serious i really need a link.


Related Posts with Thumbnails